Protect Your Brand: The Duty to Police Trademarks

So, you’ve found and registered a unique brand.  Congratulations!  That’s a major accomplishment!  However, once you have rights in a brand, you need to make sure you keep those rights in tact to protect the brand.

Although you are not required to prosecute (or even act immediately against) every potential infringer of your brands, you do have a legal duty to protect against infringement and act reasonably in protecting your trademark rights.  If you fail to properly “police” your marks, you risk diminishing the value of your brand, damaging your goodwill, and weakening your mark.police-294107_1280

In extreme cases, failure to police a mark can lead to abandonment of all trademark rights in the mark.  For example, ASPIRIN used to be a brand name owed by Bayer and ESCALATOR used to be owned by Otis Elevator Company…but these marks became so widely used as the name of the underlying products themselves that the marks became generic terms for those products, and both companies eventually lost their trademark rights in the names.  (Unlike a trademark, a generic name consists of the word commonly used to identify a product.  For example, the terms “computer,” “software” and “internet” are generic names and anyone is free to use them.)

To protect your marks and prevent competitors from using confusingly similar marks that could affect your reputation and bottom line, you should implement a plan to monitor your marks and enforce your rights when necessary.

To help you monitor your marks, you may want to sign up for Watch Services that will notify you of potential issues, such as new trademarks filed with the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), Secretary of State Offices or in foreign countries, as well as domain name filings, common law marks and corporate filings.  At the very least, you may want to set up Google Alerts to monitor mentions of your brand or products on the Internet.  If you have licensed any of your marks to third parties, you should monitor your licensees’ use of your marks as well.

In the event you become aware of a potential infringing or confusingly similar mark, you can determine (in consultation with your trademark attorney) what, if any, actions you may want to take to protect your trademark rights.  Depending on the situation, you may decide to send a cease and desist letter to the infringing party, file an Opposition or Cancellation action with the USPTO, file a lawsuit in State or Federal Court, pursue a combination of these options, or decide on a different strategy.

 

How to Protect Titles of Creative Works

Although movies, TV shows, art, books, musibooks-498422_1280c, lyrics and recordings are protected by copyright, the titles, names and tag lines associated with these types of creative works do not qualify for copyright protection. However, in certain instances, titles of creative works may be protectable as trademarks.

For example, you cannot register a trademark for the title, or a portion of a title, of a single creative work (such as a book, a television episode, a film, a live theatre production, or a phonograph record).  [NOTE: Computer software and computer games are not treated as single creative works.]

However, if the title has been (or will be) used in connection with a series of creative works (e.g., a series of books, the second edition of a book with significant changes, a periodically issued magazine, a television or movie series, a series of live performances [such as by a musical artist], educational seminars, or a continuing radio program), it may constitute a mark for either entertainment or educational services.

For more information about how to protect titles, here’s an article I wrote entitled A Different Kind of Title Insurance: How to Protect Titles of Creative Works that was published in Bloomberg BNA’s Patent, Trademark and Copyright Journal.

 

Trademark Notices

Use of the ™ or SM Symbols. Unless and until you obtain a federal trademark registration for your mark(s), you can (and should) use the ™ or SM (for trademark and service mark, respectively) symbol in connection with your marks to indicate to others that you claim rights in the marks.

You do not need to have filed a state or federal trademark application or obtained a trademark registration to use the ™ or SM symbol, as common law trademark protection subsists from the time a mark is first used in commerce…although there are several benefits to registration.

You may also want to include a trademark notice on your documents and website.

 Example: I’M WITH THE B(R)AND SM is a service mark of Danica L. Mathes. registered-98574_1280

Use of the Federal Registration Symbol ®.  You cannot use the federal registration symbol ® until you receive a federal registration certificate from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO).

Even if you have a pending trademark application, the registration symbol may not be used before the mark has actually registered. The federal registration symbol should only be used on goods or services that are the subject of the federal trademark registration.

You may also want to include a trademark notice on your documents and website.

Example: CAST A BIG SHADOW.® is a registered service mark of Bell Nunnally & Martin LLP.

NOTE:  JUST BECAUSE A MARK IS REGISTERED FOR ONE ITEM DOES NOT MEAN YOU CAN USE THE ® FOR OTHER ITEMS.  If a specific product or service is not listed in the identification of goods/services for a registered mark, then ™ or SM would be the correct notice to use in that case.

Trademark Notices in Other Countries. Some countries have severe civil and criminal penalties for improper use of trademark registration symbols.  Therefore, you should not use ® in countries where your marks have not been registered.  If you are unsure if a trademark is registered in a particular country, you should use the ™ or SM symbol.

Use of Third Party Marks.  You should observe the trademark ownership of others by including the following:

“[Enter trademark name here] is a [registered] trademark of [enter trademark owner’s name].”

If the trademark owner information is unknown, you may want to include the following:

“All trademarks are the property of their respective owners. [Company Name or Your Name] is in no way endorsed, sponsored, approved by, or otherwise affiliated with the owners of such trademarks.”

NOTE: IN MANY INSTANCES, YOU WILL LIKELY NEED PERMISSION FROM THE OWNER OF A MARK IN ORDER TO USE THAT PARTY’S MARK…especially if use of a third party mark is likely to lead consumers to believe that there is an affiliation, connection or association with the third party mark or that the owner of the third party mark sponsors, approves or originates your products, services or commercial activities.